Academic Baseball Award: Rear Admiral Frank W. Fenno’s Baseball Career
Now that the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame Class of 2017 has been announced and the debates are raging on about which of the elected are truly worthy over those who were once again overlooked, I am looking forward to the upcoming season, hopeful for the Dodgers to overcome last season’s playoff fade. The Dodgers have won the last four consecutive NL West flags and have two NLCS and two NLDS defeats to show for their efforts. Fortunately, I can fall back upon my military baseball collecting where there are both victories and defeats and yet no off-season.
Until recently, I have focused attention on acquiring photographs with a keen eye trained for uniforms to add to my collection. I have been selective, landing some vintage photos from as early as prior to WWI and into WWII, a WWII-era Hillerich and Bradsby bat (stamped U.S. Navy) and a few other assorted pieces.
One piece that I landed a few years ago caught my eye due to its uniqueness and that I hadn’t seen anything like it before (or since). Not being very in tune with the service academy athletics (beyond attending college football games that included West Point and the Air Force Academy teams and watching the annual Army/Navy football game on television) or the history as it pertains to baseball, I took particular interest in what the seller described as an athletic varsity letter (think: letterman’s jacket) for baseball from the Naval Academy in 1944. The seller had two listings: one for the letter and the other for the 1944 Lucky Bag (Annapolis’ yearbook) from the naval officer for whom the letter was awarded. Landing this letter caused me to pay closer attention to anything that might be related to baseball within the service academies.
Not long ago, I spotted an auction listing that was very unusual and a departure from my typical baseball memorabilia. The listing mentioned a medal that was awarded to a naval officer (at the time, a midshipman) who also was the recipient of three Navy Cross and one Army Distinguished Service Cross medals. This particular medal was engraved with the sailor’s name and the date that it was presented to him and was more in keeping with a sports trophy than a medal awarded for valor or esteemed service in uniform.
Frank Wesley Fenno, Jr. came to the Naval Academy with aspirations of playing professional baseball. Fenneo’s classmates wrote of him in The Lucky Bag (Annapolis’ annual), “His life’s ambition was to play baseball, and when he didn’t get in a game, it was owing to academic interference. Center field was his position and when the little pill landed in that territory, it didn’t have a chance (a warped sense of modesty prevents our telling about that home run in the Army-Navy Game).” During his years there, Frank had a reputation for both his prowess in the outfield and consistency with his bat, as further noted in The Lucky Bag, “In the outfield Fenno, Leslie, and Ward appeared to be the strongest combination. Fenno, our 1925 captain, got anything that came within the range of possibility, and all three men were handy with the stick.”
The medal, presented to Midshipmen Fenno in 1924 by the Naval Academy’s Navy Atheletic Association in recognition of his .410 batting average for his junior year baseball season. Fenno would letter in the sport for all four years before graduating and being commissioned as an ensign in 1925. Admiral Fenno would have an illustrious career as a submariner receiving the Navy’s second highest valor award (subordinate to the Medal of Honor) three times during World War II. He also received the Army’s second highest award during his WWII service. In later years, the Admiral served as the chief of staff at the United States Taiwan Defense Command where his love for the game would continue:
“I’ve been looking through your website and came across a list of Chiefs of Staff for USTDC. I was there as a photographer from 1955 to 1956 and remember that Rear Admiral Frank. W. Fenno Jr. was the Chief of Staff under Vice Admiral Stewart H. Ingersoll, the first Commander of USTDC. Since Rear Admiral Fenno is not listed, his picture is attached along with a photo of him shipping over (re-enlisting) four of the photo lab staff in August 1956. Admiral Fenno also played on the TDC softball team.” (source: US TDC Blog)
I will sheepishly admit to bidding on the medal with no prior knowledge of the admiral nor these types of medals, beating out six other bidders. In communicating with the seller in trying to obtain any provenance and history as to how he obtained the medal, I learned that this it was most-likely sold some time after his other decorations were either sold or donated.
This piece checked a lot of militaria boxes in that it was engraved with the veteran’s name, had reasonable provenance and it was directly dated. When the medal arrived, it was in its original Bailey, Banks & Biddle box (though the it is a little worn). The pendant, ribbon and clasp are all in excellent condition though the metal surfaces show some reasonable tarnish.
RADM Frank W. Fenno’s Valor Awards:
- 1st Navy Cross (April 6, 1942)
- 2nd Navy Cross (November 27, 1942)
- 3rd Navy Cross (1943)
- Distinguished Service Cross (March 17, 1942)
- Silver Star (1944)
- 1st Legion of Merit (1945)
- 2nd Legion of Merit (March 24, 1961)
WWII Commands Held:
- USS Trout (SS-202), 1941-1942
- USS Runner (SS-275), 1942 – 1943
- Commander Submarine Division 201, 1943-1945
- USS Pampanito (SS-383), 1944-1945
- Commander Submarine Division 24, 1945
- USS Pampanito: Killer Angel
- Manila Gold: Tales of the USS Trout and the War in the Pacific in World War II
Posted on January 23, 2017, in My Collection, Trophies and Awards, WWII and tagged 3-time Navy Cross Recipient, Army Distinguished Service Medal Awarded to Naval Personnel, Bailey, Banks & Biddle, DSC, Frank W. Fenno, Jr., Legion of Merit, Midshipman, Naval Academy, Naval Academy Baseball Team, Naval Submarine Commander, Navy Athletic Association, Navy Croos, USS Pampanito, USS Runner, USS Trout, WWII Submarines. Bookmark the permalink. 12 Comments.
Frank W. Fenno Jr. is my great grandfather. I occasionally do a Google search of his name to read articles to remind myself about his voyages and commit them to memory. This is the first time I came across his baseball background. I sent my mom the photos and she had a fun time reminiscing about his baseball years. Thank you so much for posting this.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Your great grandfather is one of our nation’s heroes who helped to rid the world of a horrible evil. I was happy to pursue this side of Admiral’s baseball career. I have heard from one of your relatives that your great-grandfather rejected signing with Connie Mack and the Philadelphia Athletics prior to accepting his appointment to the Naval academy. It is an honor to preserve and to share this medal and his baseball history with fans of the game and those of our nation’s legends.
Thank you! Where was this up for auction?
It was listed online a few years ago. It was being sold out of Massachusetts, if I recall correctly.
Or do you know who the seller is? Curious about its roots.
I would need to go back to see if I can find the seller. The seller did tell me that it was being sold on behalf of the medal’s previous owner who collects militaria. The seller told me that he believed that it was purchased at an estate sale in New England.
Feel free to contact the NationalWW2Museum.org in New Orleans to see if you want to loan, or donate some of that WW2 memorabilia.
Thank you for your comment.
We have not considered donating to this particular museum in the past due to some of their previous operational practices having raised concerns among donors, lenders and historians. We are not presently seeking to deaccession our collection in part or in whole. Selected items from our collection have been part of temporary exhibits in regional venues which is continuing this year.
What operational practices have raised concerns specifically?
If you’d like to discuss, send us a contact request as this sort of dialogue is better conducted offline.
Pingback: Introducing “My” Inaugural Class of the “Military Baseball Hall of Fame” | Chevrons and Diamonds
Pingback: History Must be Preserved; Militaria, Monuments and Memorials | The Veteran's Collection